News

When “Doing Good” Becomes Too Much: New Research Reveals the Hidden Mental Load of Women’s Volunteer Work

First for Women Staff

Published

on

Adobe Stock

For many women, volunteering is seen as a meaningful outlet, a way to give back, build community, and even recharge. But new research suggests that, under the wrong conditions, it can also become another source of strain layered onto already full lives.

A new national study from The Association of Junior Leagues International (AJLI) and Western Michigan University surveyed more than 2,300 women and conducted in-depth focus groups to examine a question that is often discussed but rarely measured: what happens to women’s mental health when work, caregiving, parenting, and volunteering all compete for the same finite hours?

The findings challenge the long-standing narrative that burnout is simply a matter of time management. Instead, the research points to something deeper and more complex.

It’s Not About Time. It’s About Expectations.

Across six focus groups, expectations emerged as the single largest source of strain, mentioned 117 times, far more than workload or scheduling challenges. Women described pressure coming from multiple directions: internal perfectionism, societal expectations to “do it all,” and unclear or unevenly distributed responsibilities within volunteer roles.

Rather than feeling stretched thin because of hours alone, many participants described a mental burden tied to constantly trying to meet competing expectations across every area of life.

The “Stress-Reward Cycle” of Volunteering

One of the study’s most striking insights is what researchers describe as a “stress-reward cycle.” Women reported that volunteering can be both deeply fulfilling and quietly exhausting.

In focus groups, participants described how meaningful work and positive feedback often encouraged them to take on more, even when they were already overwhelmed. One woman compared the experience to addiction: the emotional reward reinforces continued engagement, despite mounting strain.

This duality helps explain why volunteering can simultaneously support and undermine mental well-being.

Connection Is the Tipping Point

The research found that the difference between positive and negative outcomes often comes down to one critical factor: social connection.

When women felt genuinely connected to the people they volunteered with, organizational support, such as training, clear goals, and flexibility, reduced stress and improved satisfaction. But when that sense of connection was missing, those same supports were associated with higher levels of strain.

In other words, structure alone isn’t enough. Without meaningful relationships, even well-designed volunteer programs can backfire.

Strain Shows Up Everywhere

Participants described the impact of role strain as far-reaching. Physically, it showed up as insomnia, elevated blood pressure, and flare-ups of chronic illness. Emotionally, women reported guilt, overwhelm, and irritability. Socially, some experienced isolation or strain in personal relationships.

Mental health challenges were present but often less openly discussed. Several participants shared experiences with anxiety and depression, while others described severe emotional distress tied to cumulative role strain, highlighting the stigma that still surrounds these conversations.

More Roles, More Pressure

On average, women in the study reported managing 3.2 roles at once, with some juggling as many as eight. Importantly, strain wasn’t isolated to a single role. Instead, participants described a compounding effect, where everything feels overwhelming at the same time, and even managing time becomes another source of stress.

Home-related strain also played a significant role. Increased pressure at home was associated with reduced volunteer engagement, particularly among mothers, underscoring how competing demands can force difficult trade-offs.

Experience Helps, But Comes at a Cost

Older women in the study reported lower levels of strain and higher well-being. However, they attributed this not to advice or external support, but to lessons learned through experience, often the hard way.

As one participant put it: “You need to go through it to learn it.”

A Shift in How We Think About Burnout

According to AJLI CEO Melanie Schild, the findings point to a necessary reframing.

“This research tells us that burnout from volunteering is more than a time-management problem. It’s an organizational design problem,” she said. “When we build environments with genuine social connection and clear expectations, volunteering can actually improve mental well-being. Without that, it can add to the strain.”

As conversations around women’s mental health and burnout continue to evolve, the study offers a critical takeaway: supporting women isn’t just about asking them to do less, it’s about designing systems that work better.

For many women, the issue is not a lack of willingness to help. It is the pressure of trying to carry too much at once.

Trending News

Fashion5 days ago

Valerie Bertinelli, 66, Looks Like She’s ‘Aging Backwards’ as She Shows Off Her Fit Figure

TV News5 days ago

Sheinelle Jones Absent From Part of ‘Today’ Broadcast, Leaving Carson Daly to Fill in at the Last-Minute

Health4 days ago

Woman Who Undergoes 16 Pelvic Exams a Day Shares Surprising Message for Women Afraid of Pap Smears

Health6 days ago

Colin Farrell Admits He Doesn’t Know ‘Depth or Nuance’ of Son James’ Struggles With Rare Genetic Disorder

Health6 days ago

Montana Man Donated 480 Acres of Land Worth $1M in His Will to Help Advance Alzheimer’s Research

Health6 days ago

Joe Biden Says He Wouldn’t Have Gone Forward With Presidential Campaign If He’d ‘Known’ He Has Cancer

Holidays5 days ago

Joanna Gaines Reminds Us the Most Meaningful Holiday Moments Aren’t Always Picture-Perfect

HEALTH/SCIENCE5 days ago

What Men Over 50 Need to Know About the New Prostate Cancer Screening Guidelines

Sarah Paulson Sarah Paulson
Beauty5 days ago

Sarah Paulson Addresses Online Speculation She’s Had ‘Everything’ Done to Her Face

Celebrity Dads4 days ago

John Travolta Reveals He Can ‘Leave This Lifetime’ Proud of His Family With Late Wife Kelly Preston

Health4 days ago

Jill Biden Says Her ‘Whole Life Changed’ After Joe Biden’s Cancer Diagnosis, Admits It’s ‘Hard’

Real Estate4 days ago

Iconic NYC Townhouse Meg Ryan’s ‘You’ve Got Mail’ Character Lived in Hits the Market for $4 Million