Cottage Cheese Alfredo Sauce Recipe: Protein-Rich Cream Sauce

When thinking of quintessential comfort dishes, fettuccine Alfredo is one that can be too delicious to resist. Tender noodles coated in silky smooth sauce is simple yet always satisfies our creamy pasta cravings. And while there are multiple ways of preparing this dish, one that’s caught our eye recently uses cottage cheese in the sauce. The reason? Cottage cheese can be swapped for butter and cream to make a lighter yet still delicious version of creamy pasta sauce. Don’t get us wrong, we love savoring traditional cream sauce in all of its richness on occasion. However, for times when we want to be more health-conscious, cottage cheese pasta fits the bill. Keep reading to learn the ins and outs of how this dairy superfood can be transformed into a thick pasta sauce!

Why cottage cheese is a healthy pasta sauce swap

Traditional creamy sauces like Alfredo (whether store-bought or homemade) rely heavily on butter and cream. While these ingredients create the sauce’s velvety consistency, it also adds up in the nutrition department. One cup of traditional Alfredo sauce contains approximately 387 calories, 6 grams of protein and 39 grams of total fat before tossing it with pasta.

Now, if you take Alfredo sauce and swap cream and butter for cottage cheese, it’s a completely different story. The typical recipe for cottage cheese Alfredo contains about 240 calories, 18 grams of protein and 12 grams of fat per 1 cup serving.

All that extra protein can do a lot for your health. “When you digest protein, your metabolism increases,” says Florence Comite, MD, founder of the Center for Precision Medicine and Health. “Casein milk proteins are among the highest bioavailable protein sources we consume, making them perfect for those looking to lose weight.” Dr. Comite adds that casein-rich dairy like cottage cheese bulks up inside the stomach when consumed, giving the feeling of fullness.

Overall, cottage cheese pasta sauce is a great way to get this dairy’s perks while enjoying a hearty dish. (Learn more about the benefits of cottage cheese and how eating it regularly helped one woman lose 58 pounds!)

How to make the creamiest cottage cheese sauce

To create a creamy and flavorful cottage cheese sauce, follow these tips from Norah Clark, chef and editor at Boyd Hampers.

1. Choose small-curd cottage cheese.

Opt for small-curd cottage cheese as it reduces the amount of lumps in the sauce compared to large-curd types.

2. Blend the cottage cheese.

To create a velvety sauce, blend the cottage cheese in a food processor or blender for about 30 seconds prior to mixing with other ingredients. The end result will be cottage cheese with a smooth texture resembling ricotta cheese.

3. Adjust the sauce’s consistency.

When making cottage cheese pasta sauce, add 2 to 3 tablespoons of milk or chicken broth to the mixture if it starts to become overly thick. Then, taste and modify as needed to achieve your desired sauce consistency.

Best-ever cottage cheese Alfredo sauce recipe

For a luscious cottage cheese pasta sauce, follow Clark’s recipe below. All you need is 10 minutes and your cooked pasta ready to toss before enjoying a speedy and healthy weeknight meal! (Use this dairy to make these recipes for Cottage Cheese Pizza, Cottage Cheese Flatbread and more.)