The Baby-Sitters Club has revisited a longtime fan theory about one of its most beloved characters, with a new book exploring main character Kristy Thomas’ sexuality 40 years after the original series debuted.
In The Baby-Sitters Club Fan Edition: Baby-Sitter Summer, released on July 7, Kristy develops romantic feelings for another girl, a storyline that appears to confirm what some readers have suspected about the character for decades.
The novel follows the club’s famously outspoken president as she spends the summer babysitting in the fictional beach town of Bell’s Bluff, where she meets aspiring photographer Rowan Reitzes.
As the pair grow closer, Kristy begins questioning whether their connection is more than friendship.
Amazon
“My mind wandered back to Rowan,” Kristy reflects in the book, according to The U.S. Sun. “Specifically, the way my stomach felt when Rowan was around. That definitely wasn’t a normal friendship feeling, right?”
She eventually admits to Rowan, “I think – I might like girls.”
Although Kristy does not explicitly identify as a lesbian, her attraction to Rowan marks a significant development for the character, who previously had a romantic relationship with a boy named Bart Taylor in the original books.
Nonetheless, the development has delighted some longtime fans, who have speculated about Kristy’s sexuality since the original series.
“I always pictured Kristy growing up to have a wife and Subaru,” one reader wrote on Reddit. Another commented, “I knew it!” while a third added, “It’s about time! That’s really cool.”
Speaking to NPR in September, author Becky Albertalli — who wrote Kristy’s storyline in the new book — acknowledged how LGBTQ readers have long identified with the character.
“There’s no pure consensus on any one of these characters,” she said. “But she [Kristy] is a very, very beloved character among LGBT women.”
Scholastic
The novel is part of Scholastic’s 40th anniversary celebrations for The Baby-Sitters Club, which launched in 1986 with Ann M. Martin‘s Kristy’s Great Idea.
Martin returned alongside six other authors, including Becky Albertalli, Emma Straub and Sarah Kuhn, to revisit the characters for a new generation of readers.
Since its debut, the bestselling franchise has inspired a 1990 television series, a 1995 movie and a Netflix adaptation that ran for two seasons beginning in 2020.