During the Thursday, September 3, episode of The Tamsen Show Podcast, the former DWTS cohost opened up to host Tamsen Fadal about what it was like learning that she wouldn’t be asked back to the ballroom after her contract was up in 2013.
“I’ll forever ask myself what happened during that moment in my life,” Burke, who also won the seventh season of DWTS, admitted.
“My contract was up; it was being renegotiated,” Burke, 54, recalled. However, according to Burke, the transition appeared to already be “happening.”
“My dressing room was being painted,” she said. “It wasn’t like we were waiting for a negotiation. The next season was underway, and I got a call from the producers that they were making a change and that I wouldn’t be returning.”
While Burke said she realized there was “a change that was taking place,” she couldn’t stop the “inner dialogue” she was having with herself questioning why she’d been let go.
“Was it me? Nobody that loves you breaks up with you,” she said. “I was like, ‘If they really loved me so much, was I good enough?’ What kind of work was I really bringing to the ballroom? Was it my age? Are they looking for a change? Was it culture? Was it ethnicity?”
Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency / MEGA
Calling that time period in her life “complicated,” Burke said “there was a lot of turbulence in that transition.”
The mother of four also said she never really received an answer as to why she was being replaced by sports journalist Erin Andrews, who at 48 is a few years younger than Burke.
“There really wasn’t an answer other than that they wanted to make a change, and I think the host that they chose was very relevant at the time,” Burke said. “Maybe press-worthy. Maybe there was some harmony there with sports and hosting.”
“She did an absolutely fine job,” Burke said of Andrews.
Still, “Change is hard,” she admitted. “It was a really scary time because I had tremendous responsibilities — financial responsibilities. Those kind of shows don’t come along often. And there was really no prep. There was no heads up.”
Since 2023, Burke has served as host of Penn & Teller: Fool Us.