A first American edition of Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte, dating from 1848, is seen on display in the Bronte Parsonage Museum, the former home of the Bronte family and the place where their novels were written, in Haworth, northern England on February 16, 2018. - This year marks the bicentenary of the birth of Emily Bronte, the author of 'Wuthering Heights', and also the 90th anniversary of the opening of the Bronte Parsonage Museum. The museum houses the world's largest collection of Bronte manuscripts, furniture and personal possessions, and welcomed over 85,000 visitors. (Photo by OLI SCARFF / AFP) (Photo credit should read OLI SCARFF/AFP via Getty Images)
By now, you have most likely heard the latest: A new Wuthering Heights movie directed by Emerald Fennell and starringMargot Robbie and Jacob Elordi is officially in the works! But before you rush to the theaters to see it, you have to know what other adaptations came before it, some of which follow Heathcliff and Cathy’s love affair better than others, and some that are more accurate in the way they portray Heathcliff, specifically in regards to race. But even so, all of them have been great. Read on to learn our favorites.
The 1939 film: Hollywood classic but problematic
Laurence Olivier and Merle Oberon played Cathy and Heathcliff in this classic adaptation directed by William Wyler. This version was widely praised and even received six Oscar nominations and one win in the Best Cinematography, Black-and-White category. Despite all of that, much of the film feels dated and it’s one of the many adaptations that did not feature a dark skinned actor in the role of Heathcliff. However, it does contain all of the glitz and glamor of Hollywood’s golden age, so it gets bonus points for that.
You can watch the 1939 Wuthering Heights movie on Peacock.
The 2011 version: Finally, a Heathcliff of color
The 2011 Wuthering Heights could, in theory, be placed higher on the list because it was one of the adaptations that actually featured a person of color in the role of Heathcliff. James Howson took on the role alongside Kaya Scodelario—who played Cathy—and while the descriptions of the characters might have been spot on, their chemistry was not. It seemed forced and more friendly than flirty, but again, that casting really made this adaptation shine a little brighter than the rest.
And star Scodelario agreed, saying, “We stayed very true to the ages of the book, when you fall in love at 14, or when you’re a teenager, it’s different to anything you’ll ever feel again in your life.”
You can watch the 2011 Wuthering Heights movie on Peacock.
The 2009 TV series: A real-life love story
The 2009 TV adaptation of Wuthering Heights might have only been one season, but it was nothing but excellent from start to finish. In it, Charlotte Riley takes on the role of Cathy and Tom Hardy becomes Heathcliff. And while the drama and intrigue between the two might have been there, once again, Heathcliff was brought to life by a caucasian man.
A fun fact about this adaptation, though, is that Hardy and Riley fell in love on set and have been married since 2014.
Anna Calder Marshall and future James Bond Timothy Dalton took on the lead roles in the 1970 movie adaptation that truly brought to life Brontë’s themes of love, loss and obsession. It was released on Christmas Day 1970, and while this adaptation was as whitewashed as the other movies, Dalton and Marshall’s chemistry and connection almost made up for it. Plus, we couldn’t talk about this take without mentioning the haunting moment where (spoiler alert) Heathcliff goes to Cathy’s grave at the end, which, let’s be honest, was truly a step above the rest.
You can watch the 1970 Wuthering Heights movie on Tubi.
The 1992 movie: The most passionate version yet
When it comes to Wuthering Heights adaptations, the 1992 movie starring Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche truly was the best of the best. The passion and energy between the two leads were simply off the charts and the details in things like clothing, backdrops and the characters’ homes made the film feel more authentic in regards to the period. It-once again, would have been more accurate with a dark-skinned Heathcliff.
You can watch the 1992 Wuthering Heights on Pluto TV.
[ami-stories label=”For more book to film content, keep scrolling!” article1_id=”439852″ article1_title=”These 6 Movies Are Actually Better Than the Books—And the Authors Kind of Agree” article1_url=”https://firstforwomen.com/entertainment/movies-shows/movies-that-are-better-than-the-book-films-to-stream-now” article1_target=”1″ article1_nofollow=”” article1_sponsored=”” article2_id=”” article2_title=”All 8 ‘Little Women’ Adaptations, Ranked — And Where to Watch Them” article2_url=”https://firstforwomen.com/entertainment/movies-shows/little-women-movies” article2_target=”1″ article2_nofollow=”” article2_sponsored=”” article3_id=”428349″ article3_title=”7 Movies You Never Knew Were Based on Jane Austen, Ranked—From ‘Clueless’ to ‘Fire Island’” article3_url=”https://firstforwomen.com/entertainment/books/the-best-movies-based-on-jane-austen-books-including-clueless” article3_target=”1″ article3_nofollow=”” article3_sponsored=””]