Steven Bergman / AFF-USA.COM / MEGA; Steven Bergman / AFF-USA.COM / MEGA; Xavier Collin / Image Press Agency / MEGA
In the world of television, the show must go on, even if it means swapping out the stars. Behind the scenes, scheduling conflicts, creative changes, contract disputes, and unexpected health circumstances have led producers to replace actresses in some of TV’s most memorable shows.
Jane Levy
C Flanigan / imageSPACE / MEGA
Jane Levy originally took on the role of Mandy Milkovich in Shameless, but fans soon noticed Mandy’s face had changed as the actress was quietly replaced. Emma Greenwell stepped into the part starting in season two, after Levy departed to headline the ABC sitcom Suburgatory.
Jacqueline MacInnes Wood
AFF/ML/Steven Bergman / MEGA
Best known for her Emmy-winning turn on The Bold and the Beautiful, Jacqueline MacInnes Wood originally played Black Canary in Arrow‘s pilot. Scheduling conflicts ultimately forced producers to recast the role, with Caity Lotz stepping in for the series, according to CBR.
Lacey Chabert
Tony DiMaio/MEGA
Lacey Chabert voiced Meg Griffin during the first season of Family Guy, lending her unique energy to the animated favorite. The role was quietly recast, and Mila Kunis would make Meg her own starting with the show’s second season, as reported by TVLine.
Maura Tierney
Scott Kirkland / PictureGroup / MEGA
Before rising to acclaim on ER, Maura Tierney filmed the unaired pilot for Parenthood as Sarah Braverman. When the show finally moved forward, her role was recast with Lauren Graham after Tierney had to step away following a cancer diagnosis, according to Variety.
Eve Plumb
Steven Bergman/AFF-USA.COM / MEGA
Known for her iconic role as Jan Brady, Eve Plumb also briefly played Pamela Burkhard on That ’70s Show before her character was recast with movie star Brooke Shields when the role returned in season 6, per ScreenRant.
Lecy Goranson
Xavier Collin / Image Press Agency / MEGA
Lecy Goranson‘s portrayal of Becky on Roseanne became a household favorite, but her departure to attend college saw Sarah Chalke step into the role, as reported by SlashFilm. Lecy would later return to the role in 2018.
Anita Barone
KH1 / WENN / MEGA
Anita Barone made an early impression as Carol on an episode of Friends, only for the role to be recast with Jane Sibbett in the following appearances after Barone chose to pursue other opportunities, according to Cinemablend. The swift change became a memorable example of how casting tweaks can go unnoticed or become iconic trivia for die-hard fans of the series.
Sharon Wilkins
JM11 / WENN / MEGA
Sharon Wilkins had a brief appearance as Angie in 30 Rock, only to be swapped out after one episode. with Sherri Shepherd taking over the part for the rest of the series. Shepherd played the role for 11 episodes throughout the series.
Alexandra Krosney
Faye Sadou / WENN / MEGA
As Kristin on Last Man Standing, Alexandra Krosney brought warmth to the show’s family dynamic during its first season. The character was recast with Amanda Fuller as the series continued, with Krosney let go for creative reasons ahead of season two, as reported by TVLine.
Janet Hubert
Steven Bergman / AFF-USA.COM / MEGA
Janet Hubert was the original Aunt Vivian on The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, captivating audiences with her spirited performance. After creative differences, the show brought in a new actress, sparking one of TV’s most talked-about recastings, as Daphne Maxwell Reid took over the part starting in season four, according to Collider.
Laura Benanti
Steven Bergman / AFF-USA.COM / MEGA
Laura Benanti embraced the role of Supergirl’s mother on Supergirl and quickly became a fan favorite. However, commitments led to her being replaced, with Erica Durance carrying the character forward starting in season 3, as reported by Variety.